While reading "The Catcher In The Rye" I didn't really know exactly how I felt about Holden Caulfield. During chapter one, I thought I could relate to him a little bit. For example, how he was the manager of the fencing team and I was the manager of the of the basketball team, and how he forgot their fencing equipment and one time I forgot the water bottles on the bus. But what makes us different is that I felt awful about it, but he thought it was funny and it didn't bother him at all. However, as I kept reading, I started realizing that I wasn't much like him at all, and that personally I think he is kind of irritating. I say this because he gets off topic or he repeats himself.
"...Then I got this book I was reading and sat down in my chair. There were two chairs in every room. I had one and my roommate, Ward Stradlater, had one. The arms were in sad shape, because everybody was always sitting on them, but they were pretty comfortable chairs." I don't understand why he has to go into so much detail, like we don't need to know that the arms of the chairs were crappy. Another time when he repeats himself is when he is talking to Stradlater about Jane Gallagher. He just keeps talking about how they played checkers and she always kept her kings on the back line because she liked how it looked, and then he just kept saying "Jane Gallagher, Jesus." Like we get it, you were good friends and you like her.
However, I think is is like the typical teenage because when he was talking about how he didn't feel bad about about leaving the equipment, he could have just been saying that because is didn't want to admit it. I think that I empathize with him sometimes, because I try to say that I am not bothered by something or I don't admit my true feelings because I don't want to be seen as "weak" or whatever. And also feel like I can relate to him when he gets bored and horses around because I get bored a lot and I make up a game or just start dancing randomly. Like how he was acting like a tap-dancer in the restroom. "The leading man can't go on. He's as drunk as a bastard. So who do they get to take his place? Me, that's who. The little ole goddam Governor's son." I would do that same thing, make up a crazy story that has nothing to do with what was going on. I think Holden is an okay guy, but can get a little irritating sometimes, but I am looking foward to finishing the book.
First off... jeez woman you can write! I am impressed! Second off I like how you mentioned your amazing manager job. The difference between you and Holden in the management department is that you would never forget our stuff on the bus. I really like how you commented on both sides of Holden. The good side and the bad side. I agree he can get a tad irritating though
ReplyDeleteHi Aja. I want you to reread that passage where Holden is thinking about Jane Gallagher. Think about how Stradlater treats his date with her, and how that contrasts with how Holden views her. Yes, I admit, it's random that he remembers how she played checkers and kept her kings in the back row, but might this also show us more into Holden. What is the significance in the way she played checkers? Why does Holden still remember that? How would you feel if you had a boy from your childhood that remembered these tiny, yet important details about you??? Flattered or completely creeped out?
ReplyDeleteI agree with Rachel! I think it was cool how you analyzed both sides of Holden. Also, I liked how you were able to relate to Holden about leaving the equipment on the bus. You also picked really good quotes to back up your examples. I thought it was interesting you thought he was annoying and can see your point of view now!
ReplyDeleteI really like how you compared and contrasted yourself to Holden. O like how you chose to write about the pros and cons with Holden! You really made me think about some things I had never thought about him before. You did a very good job with finding your quotes and how they got your point across!I like how you chose to write about the small things that Holden talked about in the book! Your blog was very interesting to read! Oh and by the way you were a great manager!! :) Great job Aja
ReplyDelete